Democrats, gerrymanders, and the 15-year shellacking

Or, how Barack Obama’s victory caused the demise of the Voting Rights Act

This is why we can’t have nice things – like, you know, democracy.

We can’t sugarcoat this: The Democrats have failed spectacularly at the challenge of redistricting, going back almost 20 years. Today, we are reaping the impossibly bitter fruits of that failure, and this new reality is devastating our country.

Let’s remember back to 2008, when Barack Obama was first elected president and America seemed to be on the brink of something wonderful. It was joyous.

But while we were giggling over the White House’s clever new take on turkey pardoning, the Republicans were strategizing. Plotting. Scheming.

They noticed that 2010 was coming right up – which meant a new census, followed by redistricting. They understood that all those new districts would be drawn by state legislatures, according to each state’s partisan make-up.

Initially, that didn’t seem like a big worry. Heading into the 2010 general elections, about 60 percent of the states’ legislative chambers were held by Democratic majorities. (If you want to get technical about it, there are 88 legislative chambers overall, and 52 had Democratic majorities, while two were equally split.) And honestly, there wasn’t much attention given to state-level races when there was so much going on at the Congressional level.

Then came the bloodbath of the 2010 Congressional election – 63 seats lost in the House, and six in the Senate. So there wasn’t much attention initially to the nationwide disasters at the state level.

Republicans won majorities in in 53 state chambers. They took complete control over redistricting in 17 states (including Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, and Wisconsin), which gave them the power to draw 173 U.S. House seats (as well as their own legislative districts, of course.) By contrast, Democrats held the reins on redistricting in only six states. The rest (including California) were in the hands of independent commissions and state and federal judges.

The result: In 2012, Republican-drawn maps enabled the GOP to hang on to a 33-seat majority in the House, even though Democratic candidates won 1.17 million more votes than Republicans nationwide. It was only the second time in 70 years that a party won a majority of Congressional votes but wound up with a minority of House seats.

That’s when we finally started talking about the problem of “gerrymandering” – drawing districts that are carefully (and unfairly) designed to hand victory to a particular party or candidate.

The problem is, we let the GOP frame the conversation. So people wound up with the cockamamie idea that you can tell whether a district is gerrymandered just by looking at it.

Quick quiz: Is this district gerrymandered?

I mean, it must be, right? All those wiggles and squiggles?

Here’s the thing – the southern border of that district is the state line between Maryland and Virginia. So if you think it looks funny, take it up with the Potomac River.

Compare with this generally tidy-looking proposed district. There’s that one weird bit in the southeast corner, but otherwise pretty respectable. Right?

Nope. This is actually one of the most gerrymandered districts ever drawn, because that squiggly bit snatches a clump of Democrats in Austin TX and dilutes their power by grouping them with rural Republicans who live 300 miles away.

Then there’s this – the infamous Illinois 4th, better known as the “crab claw” district, which became a poster child of sorts for “gerrymandering.”

Except it’s not. It’s a great example of a district that was successfully drawn to make sure Illinois’ Hispanic communities were fairly represented in Congress – as required by law under the Voting Rights Act.

If we’d been smarter, we would have thrown a very public fit every time a district like this one was hauled out as an example of “gerrymandering.” We would have repeated the mantra that gerrymandering isn’t about the way the district looks; it’s about the people who live in it. We would have burned up the phone lines complaining to newspaper editors, tv news producers, late-night hosts, good government organizations, and anybody else who trotted out a picture of a wiggly district as proof of “partisan” gerrymandering. Most importantly, we would have invoked the Voting Rights Act every single time someone started talking about “fair maps.”

Because the real question, of course, is “fair for whom?”

The good government folks (including groups that were quietly funded by Republicans) kept talking about drawing “competitive” districts, as if that was the best metric of fairness. But a truly fair map isn’t about giving both candidates a chance to win; it’s about giving voters a fair shot at electing someone who will represent their interests.

Sometimes it’s fair to assume that people who live near each other are pretty much like each other and have roughly similar interests – think of “lifestyle enclaves” in suburban Chicago, or rural communities dotted across the broad open lands of the upper Midwest.

But when districts are drawn based on geography rather than people, they can perpetuate a history of segregation, red-lining, and systemic racism. That’s why the Voting Rights Act reached beyond poll taxes, literacy tests, and other voter suppression tactics to address the ways district maps were drawn to violate the principle of equal rights and minimize the power of minority voters.

It’s baffling to me that we didn’t rise up as a party a decade ago and start insisting on a definition of “fair maps” that would enshrine the idea that minority communities deserve a voice in Congress.

This was an educable moment for American voters, and we biffed it.

Now we’re facing the threat of a grim new era of Jim Crow, made possible by the visceral racism of GOP leadership and the Roberts Supreme Court, with the unwitting assistance of all the Democrats who chuckled and nodded when wrong-headed critics displayed districts drawn like Rorschach tests as proof of “gerrymandering.”

Nobody wants to hear this, but we can’t treat victory in November as our end goal. Starting on Nov. 4, we have to be ready to embark on an enormous American civics education program, with a special focus on the connection between voters, districts, and democracy.

This time, we need to make sure everybody understands that, with congressional districts, as with so much in life, looks can be deceiving. It’s what’s inside that counts.

To help the DNC save democracy, click here.